My dear friends,
Can you please leave me some comments about my icon design?
I need your help.
Please be honest for your comment.
Don’t think about it will hurt me or not.
Can you please leave me some comments about my icon design?
I need your help.
Please be honest for your comment.
Don’t think about it will hurt me or not.
Just tell me the truth.
I may accept your comment and refine my icon design.
Let’s start……
1. What is the theme of my icon?
a. Clown
b. Snow white
c. Camp
d. Cake
2. Can you recognized what the icon is?/Is it easy to recognized?
a. can for both
b. can recognized pixel icons
c. can recognized vector icons
d. cannot (why??please tell me)
3. How does the colour combination? How about the design?
a. Good. ____________.
b. Average. __________.
c. Poor._____________.
4. Is there anything that you think I need to change/refine? Can give me some suggestion?
Ex. Colour, shape, lighting, shadow………
_______________________________________
d. Cake
2. Can you recognized what the icon is?/Is it easy to recognized?
a. can for both
b. can recognized pixel icons
c. can recognized vector icons
d. cannot (why??please tell me)
3. How does the colour combination? How about the design?
a. Good. ____________.
b. Average. __________.
c. Poor._____________.
4. Is there anything that you think I need to change/refine? Can give me some suggestion?
Ex. Colour, shape, lighting, shadow………
_______________________________________
Thank You^^
c???
ReplyDeletea
b,cause just like normal ppl thinking...no special
i think colour...and the design for pixel like a bit blur..not clear enough
Pei Wen : can comment at chat box...
ReplyDelete1)snow white
ReplyDelete2)if is phone and house then is(a)
if not then i will go for (d)
3)average
4)the icon is too colourful
1b Actually i think u make ur theme more strong, if add on the character of Snow White. (example : 7 short boy's hat, poison apple and other else)
ReplyDelete2a
3a
4b have any shadow for your icon? lol just theme not enough strong. (please do not mind what i said) :P
1d
ReplyDelete2a
3good
4maybe some shadow on it...
yr design looks lk cake...feel lk in world of fairy tale...i don't mean childish...it's my feel...
1) c
ReplyDelete2) c
3) b
4) the design is so so, the color still acceptable, have to put some effort on shadow. =)
but, good try~
from
-ks-
kvn here to leave u a comment ^^
ReplyDelete1)clown~
2)a
3)b
4)haha..sure, i like to comment ppl 1 XD...er hem...
firstly,ya..the vector and pixel almost is same, but i talk to the vector contact 1st..the telefone does not so obvious actually, maybe u can try make the top part largest abit?and u can play some shadow?because wat i see now is abit solid..u can play around with few layer of gradient?but the pixel contact compare to vector rite is more obvious to recognize is a phone..home facing the same probelm of shadow lo..coz the roof on top and overlap the bady ma..so u can make more deep shadow?and the home pixel u can try to make a line of darker colour below the roof?mayb~~this my suggestion la..(^.<)
1.C
ReplyDelete2.C
3.B
4.Colour can be more sharp a bit
1. snow white for sure. but pixel & vector icon home cant really represent snow white theme if just see it by alone. do u think so ?
ReplyDelete2. can recognice.
3. colour combination is ok. cause snow white's colour is like that and dont know change to what colour also. right ?
4. your vector phone is nice. colour and shape also very ok de. just that quite flat. u know it right ? try to make it more 3D ba. will be perfect de. same to the vector home.
^^
apa.
1.应该是SNOW WHITE吧？
ReplyDelete2.不容易记得，因为特征不明显，没有特别吸引人，不能让人留下深刻的印象....
3.颜色..你用了snowwhite的颜色，蓝，黄，粉红，确实是可以显示到你在做snowwhite的theme，但是，你的颜色分量用得太均匀，所以没有focuspoint,显示不到特点，还有主题
4.首先，你的icon给我的第一印象是cake...但是很明显的，你用了snowwhite的颜色...所以如果你没有答案给我选的话，我会觉得像蛋糕=.=,所以我也很想知道你的theme是什么？？
所以以下的我会针对snowwhite的theme来答...
其实也不要忘记snow"white"的白，因为如果用白来带snowwhite的color效果可能没那么乱，能够比较明显...再来就是图案的设计看不出有什么point...如果在pixel跟vector来看的话，你的pixel icon会比较好，因为在vector就变得很flat...
纯属个人意见，加油~~~~
1) seriously, icons look like cake. although i knw is snow white
ReplyDelete2)a
3)b
4)maybe ur colour is all very light colour, try if put some darker colour on it maybe will more nicer...hehe...try different colours la...maybe can help u discover new things....
1.B
ReplyDelete2.C (i research for the snow white phone,the 袖子 colour is lighter than the shirt colour,and for the camp,i dunno wat it stand for ? but the house or camp no giv me the snow white feel for me)
3.B ( not bad, above average )
4.if the circle of the phone make it red like apple will looks like how leh？The house or camp is it a circus camp ? i like ur vector phone also,quite cute,hahaha,i think just the house,camp or a circus camp make me guesing ...
Gambateh ...hahaha^^
1.B.Show White
ReplyDelete2.A
3.B.hmm..the colour contrast not really good enough. should put some effort
4.as all of ur friends said. should do smth with the shading part. change the top part of the house to a lil bigger should be more okay i think.
1. snow white
ReplyDelete2. vector icons
3. average
4. left: i think d light s not very bright compare 2 d right wan..
left: i think d body shape s not look alike as the telephone lo..but..i not very sure whether u wan to draw telephone o not la..i think s telephone la..><
1) d
ReplyDelete2) a
3) b
4) i don't feel blue and yellow are match.
1)sry... can't really recognize it... clown? snow white?
ReplyDelete2)for both also can
3)good
4)try different color changes and different of light tone... i think it can be better.
1. Snow white, becos i noe d~ hehe~
ReplyDelete2. Can for both but little bit only~(sry abt tat!)
I cant the special part u noe?
Actually if i hear from jossie, i really dun
noe u r doing snow white.
3. Average. The colour combine quite ok. but
lighting got some problem, look too flat,
specially the contact of the vector icon.
if you dun understand wat i m saying, call
me.
4. yes, aiyo~ too many things lah~ you just
call me or i go ur house tell u la~ lazy to
type~ hhaha~
1. What is the theme of my icon?
ReplyDeletea. Clown ( 1st thought was this)..but when i tried to look for several times again, i think shud be Snow White.
2. Can you recognized what the icon is?/Is it easy to recognized?
c. can recognized vector icons
(contact for pixel yes. but home for pixel might not that obvious)
3. How does the colour combination? How about the design?
a. Good. ____________. Snow white for the theme..the colour that u applied is related to snow white...haha..kinda good..
4. Is there anything that you think I need to change/refine? Can give me some suggestion?
*so far, i think can change more in terms of lighting..can apply highlight and shadow..although u've applied gradient, that doesnt really show the 3D feel...look kind flat..=)
Chien2..thanks and sorry if i've said something offensive..lol...
Ex. Colour, shape, lighting, shadow………
1 b
ReplyDelete2 a
3 b
4 looks flat...can improve more i mean make it more 3D anyway i like the vector part ^^